Decisions & Appeals

The Real Estate Council of Alberta (RECA) is responsible for ensuring Alberta consumers who use the services of a real estate licensee, mortgage licensee, property manager, or condominium manager are adequately protected. Under the Real Estate Act, RECA has the authority to hold formal hearings to inquire into possible licensees breaches of the Act and discipline misconduct when appropriate. For more information about the different types of disciplinary decisions, go to Types of Decisions.

RECA withholds the publication of decisions until the 30-day right of appeal period expires, except where a matter is egregious and would support earlier publication in the interest of consumer protection. Decisions will remain on reca.ca for 5 years. Submit a Request for Disciplinary History form to access decisions that are no longer available on the website.

Browse the list below or use the search tool* to look for a specific industry licensee.
*Do not include any punctuation in your search names. E.g., if the last name of the professional you are searching for is O’Neil, enter “ONeil” or “oneil.”

Search Decisions & Appeals

Date
Name
Section of Legislation Breached
Type of Decision
Outcome
January 08, 2024 Gagandeep Singh Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b) & 43(1) Appeal Panel Decision Appeal Dismissed. No additional costs awarded. Nov 2022 Hearing Panel Decision stands. Licences canceled (may reapply after Dec 1, 2030); $80,000 for breaches of Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b).
December 13, 2023 Casurt Roy Morgan Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b) Hearing Panel Decision pending appeal—Licence canceled (may reapply after December 13, 2026); $30,000 for breaches of Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b); $15,620 in costs.
November 23, 2023 Pedro Villamar Real Estate Act Rules s.41(d) Administrative Penalty $1,500
November 23, 2023 Travis Peter John More Real Estate Act s.17(c) & (d) Administrative Penalty $10,000
November 23, 2023 Christine Le Real Estate Act Rules s.41(d) Administrative Penalty $1,500
October 31, 2023 Rebecca Rae Mayhew Real Estate Act Rules s.41(d) Administrative Penalty $1,500
October 31, 2023 Han Thuan Huynh Real Estate Act Rules s.58(i) Administrative Penalty $1,500
October 26, 2023 Mary Virginia Walker Real Estate Act Rules s.41(d) Administrative Penalty $1,500
October 19, 2023 Jagseer Singh "Deep" Nirwan Real Estate Act Rules s.54(1)(c) Administrative Penalty $3,000
August 16, 2023 Gagandeep Singh Real Estate Act s.17(a) and (b) Hearing Panel Decision $25,000 for breach of Real Estate Act s.17(a); $15,000 for breach of Real Estate Act s.17(b); four additional Administrative Penalties withdrawn. (appeal closed)
August 15, 2023 Anthony Phillip Schumacher Real Estate Act Rules s.41(a) & (b); 42(a) & (g) Hearing Panel Decision Written reprimand for breach of Real Estate Act Rules s.41(a) & (b); 42(a) & (g)
July 31, 2023 Tsz Kan Ng Real Estate Act Rules s.91(4) Administrative Penalty $1,500
June 26, 2023 Shaun Johal Real Estate Act Rules s.54(1)(e) Administrative Penalty $1,500
June 26, 2023 Bhalinder Singh Dhaliwal Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b) Hearing Panel Decision Licence canceled (may reapply after June 26, 2024)
May 29, 2023 Anson Yiu Cheung Real Estate Act Rules s.91(4) Administrative Penalty $1,500
May 18, 2023 Yu Song Real Estate Act Rules s.91(4) Administrative Penalty $1,500
May 18, 2023 Solomon Aloysius Davies Real Estate Act Rules s.91(4) Administrative Penalty $1,500
May 18, 2023 Rahmon Adegbola Real Estate Act s.17(c) Administrative Penalty $1,000
May 11, 2023 Shane Cameron Voth Real Estate Act s.38(4)(a); Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b) Hearing Panel Decision Licence canceled (may reapply after May 10, 2026); $10,000 for breaches of Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b); $5,000 for breach of Real Estate Act s.38(4)(a); $1,500 in costs.
May 08, 2023 Patrick Fraser Real Estate Act s.17(c) Administrative Penalty $25,000
April 17, 2023 Farouk Mohamed Real Estate Act s.17(a); Real Estate Act Rules s.53(a) and s.53(d) Hearing Panel Decision pending appeal—$15,000 for breach of Real Estate Act s.17(a); $10,500 for breaches of Real Estate Act Rules s.53(a); $5,000 for breach of Real Estate Act Rules s.53(d); $11,000 in costs
April 13, 2023 Sabah Al-Hamidi Real Estate Act s.38(4)(a) Administrative Penalty $5,000
April 03, 2023 Azher Haleem Chaudhary Real Estate Act s.17(b) Administrative Penalty $25,000
April 03, 2023 Azher Haleem Chaudhary Real Estate Act s.17(a) Administrative Penalty $25,000
March 28, 2023 Caren Sylvia Kelley Real Estate Act Rules s.41(c), 41(d), 41(g), 43(3), & 57(a) Hearing Panel Decision Licence canceled (may reapply after June 28, 2023); $20,000 for breaches of Real Estate Act Rules s.41(c), 41(d), 41(g), 43(3), & 57(a); $7,642 in costs.
March 16, 2023 Jacky Chen Real Estate Act s.17(c) Administrative Penalty $25,000
March 16, 2023 Jacky Chen Real Estate Act s.17(c) Administrative Penalty $25,000
February 13, 2023 Gagandeep Singh Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b) & 43(1) Hearing Panel Decision Licences canceled (may re-apply after Dec 1, 2030); $80,000 for breaches of Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b); $23,465 in costs.
January 31, 2023 Michael Robert Holmes Real Estate Act s.25(1)(d) Administrative Penalty $15,000
January 18, 2023 Anna Marzena Trojanowicz Real Estate Act Rules s.41(b) Hearing Panel Decision $3,000

January 08, 2024

Gagandeep Singh

Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b) & 43(1)

Appeal Panel Decision

December 13, 2023

Casurt Roy Morgan

Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b)

Hearing Panel Decision

November 23, 2023

Pedro Villamar

Real Estate Act Rules s.41(d)

Administrative Penalty

November 23, 2023

Travis Peter John More

Real Estate Act s.17(c) & (d)

Administrative Penalty

November 23, 2023

Christine Le

Real Estate Act Rules s.41(d)

Administrative Penalty

October 31, 2023

Rebecca Rae Mayhew

Real Estate Act Rules s.41(d)

Administrative Penalty

October 31, 2023

Han Thuan Huynh

Real Estate Act Rules s.58(i)

Administrative Penalty

October 26, 2023

Mary Virginia Walker

Real Estate Act Rules s.41(d)

Administrative Penalty

October 19, 2023

Jagseer Singh "Deep" Nirwan

Real Estate Act Rules s.54(1)(c)

Administrative Penalty

August 16, 2023

Gagandeep Singh

Real Estate Act s.17(a) and (b)

Hearing Panel Decision

August 15, 2023

Anthony Phillip Schumacher

Real Estate Act Rules s.41(a) & (b); 42(a) & (g)

Hearing Panel Decision

July 31, 2023

Tsz Kan Ng

Real Estate Act Rules s.91(4)

Administrative Penalty

June 26, 2023

Shaun Johal

Real Estate Act Rules s.54(1)(e)

Administrative Penalty

June 26, 2023

Bhalinder Singh Dhaliwal

Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b)

Hearing Panel Decision

May 29, 2023

Anson Yiu Cheung

Real Estate Act Rules s.91(4)

Administrative Penalty

May 18, 2023

Yu Song

Real Estate Act Rules s.91(4)

Administrative Penalty

May 18, 2023

Solomon Aloysius Davies

Real Estate Act Rules s.91(4)

Administrative Penalty

May 18, 2023

Rahmon Adegbola

Real Estate Act s.17(c)

Administrative Penalty

May 11, 2023

Shane Cameron Voth

Real Estate Act s.38(4)(a); Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b)

Hearing Panel Decision

May 08, 2023

Patrick Fraser

Real Estate Act s.17(c)

Administrative Penalty

April 17, 2023

Farouk Mohamed

Real Estate Act s.17(a); Real Estate Act Rules s.53(a) and s.53(d)

Hearing Panel Decision

April 13, 2023

Sabah Al-Hamidi

Real Estate Act s.38(4)(a)

Administrative Penalty

April 03, 2023

Azher Haleem Chaudhary

Real Estate Act s.17(b)

Administrative Penalty

April 03, 2023

Azher Haleem Chaudhary

Real Estate Act s.17(a)

Administrative Penalty

March 28, 2023

Caren Sylvia Kelley

Real Estate Act Rules s.41(c), 41(d), 41(g), 43(3), & 57(a)

Hearing Panel Decision

March 16, 2023

Jacky Chen

Real Estate Act s.17(c)

Administrative Penalty

March 16, 2023

Jacky Chen

Real Estate Act s.17(c)

Administrative Penalty

February 13, 2023

Gagandeep Singh

Real Estate Act Rules s.42(b) & 43(1)

Hearing Panel Decision

January 31, 2023

Michael Robert Holmes

Real Estate Act s.25(1)(d)

Administrative Penalty

January 18, 2023

Anna Marzena Trojanowicz

Real Estate Act Rules s.41(b)

Hearing Panel Decision